Aluminum Bats Vs Wooden Bats Is Baseball example essay topic

Aluminum Bats vs. Wooden Bats Is baseball America's pastime? For the major leagues maybe, but for college athletes it seems more like a new age video game. The introduction of high dollar ed aluminum bats produce football like scores, higher statistics, and a percentage of danger to each and every player on the field. The NCAA has changed the regulations of the bats so far and should look further into to making another change to wooden bats. High tech aluminum baseball bats aren't quite as new to the game as many people may think. Author, Patrick Hruby, wrote in Sports Illustrated, "introduced in the mid-1970's... metal bats have become increasingly potent, forged with alloys... pressurized air chambers" (Hruby 42).

Over the last few decades these aluminum 'killer bats' have evolved to be even more potent. "Some coaches and players claim these powerful bats are ruining the integrity of the game and placing pitchers at undue risk" (42). Every college, divisions I through, are using these bats religiously. Each year bigger and better bats are at each team's fingertips.

A few of the more popular bats this year are the TPX C 555 Platinum, TPX Omaha, and the EASTON Redline, just to name a few. These bats are so advanced that almost everything about them has changed, for instance, .".. an expanded "sweet-spot"- the area of the bat that produces maximum hitting power. While the sweet spot on a wood bat is roughly 6 to 8 inches long, aluminum sweet spots can be twice that size" (43). James Braham, a writer for Machine Design, says that the new "aluminum baseball bats have actually taken over an estimated 90 to 95% of the market, with wood bats remaining largely in the professional major and minor baseball leagues" (James 56).

Another exciting characteristic of aluminum bats is the speed at which the ball leaves the bat compared to the speed that it leaves a wooden bat. A one time representative of Louisville Slugger, J.W. MacKay, says "When a ball is traveling at 94 miles per hour as it leaves the bat, a pitcher has four milliseconds to respond... you can't react that fast" (Palmer 2). Studies show the bats have enough power to propel balls at speeds up to 123 miles per hour, up to 30 mph faster than balls struck with wooden bats. In a memorandum written to the NCAA, Cedric W. Dempsey states that "traditional wood bats when swung at 70 miles per hour at a ball moving at 70 mph will produce an exit velocity of approximately 93 mph or less. Aluminum bats regularly produce exit velocities in excess of 97 mph under the same conditions" (Dempsey 2). Besides the velocity of the ball coming off of the bat there is also the reaction time to look at.

"Baseball Rules Committee believe that a collegiate pitcher needs approximately. 4 seconds to react and move to avoid being struck... a pitcher is between 51 and 52 feet away from the point of impact between the bat and ball at the time of impact" (3). Dempsey also states that "at 94 mph the ball will travel 52 feet in approximately. 371 seconds... with high power aluminum bats speeds well in excess of 100 mph the ball will travel 52 feet in. 354 seconds... at 110 mph, a ball will travel 52 feet in. 321 seconds" (3).

Baseball bats aren't the only things that are changing; in fact it is the aluminum bats that are changing the game. If you asked players who only played with wooden bats, like the legendary Babe Ruth, Mickey Mantle, or even Willie Keeler they would all say that these aluminum bats are taking away from the real game of baseball. These Hall of Fame players aren't the only ones thinking that it takes away from the game, Bill Thurston, Amherst College's baseball coach said "All you have to do is talk to pro scout, ... They think the college game is ridiculous" (Hruby 42). They think that it is ridiculous because the bats that collegiate players use are helping turn baseball scores into football like scores. A perfect example of this is the 1998 season "During the 1998 College World Series, a total of 48 records were broken and 32 were tied... in addition, in the championship game Southern California defeated Arizona State 21-14... there were 62 home runs hit, compared to the previous record of 48 set in 1995" (Dempsey 3).

Not only are the scores skyrocketing, but players of today have statistics that have also shot up like rocket. Hruby says in his article that "Since the introduction of the aluminum bats, team batting average in Division I has increased 41 points. Home runs per team per game have more than doubled to 1.07. The average pitcher's ERA has ballooned to 6.09" (Hruby 43). The art of hitting with a wooden baseball bat has become almost extinct; this is due to the aluminum bat. It has made people who would be average hitters into above average hitters.

Evidence of this is in Hruby's article, he states "a committee tracked 75 Division I hitters and 48 pitchers who competed in the Cape Cod League that uses wooden bats... then compared their Cape Cod numbers with their 1998 regular season statistics... with wood players hit just. 232 with a home run once every 69 at-bats. With aluminum, those same players hit. 334 and homered every 19 at-bats. And for the pitchers, average ERA mushroomed from 2.80 to 4.62" (43).

Another point about the higher statistics is that in college a very good hitter will hit over. 420; a very good hitter in the major leagues only dreams about hitting. 400. Actually, there has been one player to hit over.

400. In an interview with head baseball coach of the Florida State Seminoles, Mike Martin, he brings up the topic of high scoring; "From the coaching standpoint, we are doing everything we can to keep the other team from scoring. But if we can win 8-7 or 11-8... it's just the way it is these days" (Weber 49). With the information provided, one can see that the higher velocity of the ball of the bat has increased runs and statistics, but it has done more. Nowadays, there is always a little fear in the back of each players mind. The facture of danger in increased dramatically over the last few years.

Miami's head coach, Jim Morris, says in an article by Kostya Kennedy that "the feeling is pretty widespread that the game is unbalanced to the point that it's not only in favor of hitters, but dangerous for pitchers and fielders" (Kennedy 27). In 1996, pitcher Ryan Mills of Arizona State and Danny Crawford of Houston both were hit in the head by line drives. Mills suffered a broken jaw, while Crawford received 62 stitches to his face and lost five teeth- one of which later was found by a Texas A&M groundskeeper who mailed it back to Crawford" (Hruby 42). Bill Thurston, a rules editor for the NCAA, says "the injuries starting popping up when the C 405 aluminum alloy came out as the bat standard in 1996" (Mravic 34).

This trend of injury is not only up there with the best college players, but also with little leagues. In an article by David Seifman, James Od do "also pointed to news accounts of 14 incidents since 1994 where aluminum bats injured- or killed- young players" (Seifman 1). In an interview with Matt Patterson, a former college baseball player, we discussed the issue of the new aluminum bats. Since Patterson pitched in college he had first hand experience with the velocity of the baseball from the bats.

The first question about the bats that was asked was "Did it make it more dangerous for the pitcher?" His reply to the question was that he had more fear. "The bats they are using contain air pouches inside the aluminum. That just sounds too scientific for baseball without it being dangerous". Another question asked was "Do you really think that these bats take away from the game of baseball?" Patterson answers; "the game was traditionally played like a chess match, it was more about out witting the other team as well as scoring more runs. Today in the game of college baseball it is all about who can hit the ball the farthest or how many runs can we score in one inning; it's almost like a circus". One of the final questions to Patterson "What would you like to see happen over the next couple of years with the bat debate?" Answer: "I would like to see the NCAA resort the new wooden bats created with the foam (Baum bats) or the wooden bats that are actually in a unbreakable shell (Composite bats).

I think that would make for better MLB players and more excitement where it belongs, in the Big Leagues". Wooden baseball bats are a thing of the past, but is it possible for them to be a thing of future? That would not be a bad idea at all for the NCAA to make; with research they now know the velocity of impact between ball and bat. That alone is the thing that has raised the scores and statistics all around the game. Along with the high velocity and big numbers there is now more than ever a risk of being seriously injured.

"The Executive Committee changed the bat specifications t o enhance player safety, to restore the competitive balance in the game between offense and defense, and to preserve the integrity of the game... Executive Committee chose an implementation of date of August 1 1999" (Dempsey 1). If this is America's pastime then it should stay the way that America created it. [1643]

Bibliography

Braham, Jones. "Keep Your Eye on the Bat". Machine Design 63.13 (1997).
29 Mar. 2002 web Hruby, Patrick.
Hitters like high-tech bats, but critics smell foul play". Insight on the News 15.27 (1999).
29 Mar. 2002 web Kennedy, Kostya.
Heavy Metal". Sports Illustrated 86.4 (1997).
29 Mar. 2002 web McCallum, Jack;
O'brien, Richard. "Stati tudes". Sports Illustrated 88.18 (1998).
29 Mar. 2002 web Mravic, Mark.
Killer Bats?" Sports Illustrated 92.13 (2000).
29 Mar. 2002 web NCAA Baseball Rules Committee.
Easton Sports' Recent Letters". National Collegiate Athletic Association. 4 Dec. 1998.
5 Apr. 2002 web Palmer, Bob.
MacKay asks government to recall metal bats. 5 Apr. 2002 web Patterson, Matt.
Interview". 5 Apr. 2002.
Seifman, David. "Pols Would Toss Metal Bats From Kid Games". New York Post. com. 28 Jun. 2001.
5 Apr. 2002 web Weber, Ben.
For Success: Lots of Scoring". Coach & Athletic Director 1.4 (2000).
29 Mar. 2002 web.