Audience's Sympathy For Shylock example essay topic

How far is Shylock a character for whom we can feel sympathy? How would a contemporary audience's response to him differ from that of an audience in Shakespeare's time? Shylock isn't a character for whom we can feel much sympathy for because he always seems to be thinking about himself and his money rather than other people around him. Through most of the play he seems selfish, and it seems in some parts of the play as though he doesn't care about his daughter.

He also has a very strict religion, which also sometimes makes him seem as an uptight character. Although he sometimes does try and be a good father to his daughter such as in act 2, scene 3. This is where he tells her to lock the house up and to keep safe from the masque, but even part of this act to his daughter was to make sure no Christian men would come into his house or anything get stolen. Through the whole of the play the audience keeps changing their sympathy for Shylock, pitying him one moment and hating him the next.

Some people would call the audience's feelings to Shylock a kind of roller coaster of sympathy. Also in act 2, scene 8 Sale rio and Solanio are talking about the way Shylock reacted to his daughter leaving. Solanio said that Shylock had said:' My daughter! O my ducats! O my daughter!' This quote makes the audience feel a tiny bit of sympathy for Shylock as it shows how he feels awful about how he has lost his daughter and money at the same time. Solanio also goes on to say:'s to len by my daughter!

Justice! Find the girl! She hath the stones upon her, and the ducats!' After this is said the audience will feel a lot less sympathy for Shylock as it seems he only cares about finding his daughter because she has the ducats with her and the only way to get back his ducats etc is to find his daughter. Although he only cares about his ducats the audience might feel sympathy for him because that it was his own flesh and blood that stole the ducats from him.

So Shylock would feel quite betrayed by this. In act 3, scene 1 there is a lot of evidence that shows Shylock valuing money over his daughter. Shylock had said in this scene:' I would my daughter were dead at my foot, and the jewels in her ear; would she were he arsed at my foot, and the ducats in her coffin. ' This shows that he would rather see his own daughter die than lose his money and jewels. This is a very selfish act and will make the audience feel a lot less sorry for Shylock. Some of the audience might not even feel any sympathy for Shylock at this time in the play.

Also during this scene Shylock is told that Antonio's ships might be ship wrecked. This is when Shylock then says:' I am very glad of it - I'll plague him, I'll torture him - I am glad of it. ' This quote shows him as a very ruthless and horrible man because of the very strong words used like 'plague' and 'torture'. The audience will think that Shylock is a man who would rather have revenge than have his own daughter back. Also later in this scene Sala rio and Solanio had been talking rudely to Shylock, one thing they had said to Shylock was: 'There is more difference between thy flesh and hers than between jet and ivory. ' This would have made the audience feel sympathy for Shylock.

Then Shylock says his long speech (this speech is said to be the most famous speech in the whole play). This part is the most relevant of the speech:' I am a Jew. Hath not a Jew eyes? Hath not a Jew hands, organs, dimensions, senses, affections, passions? This will make the audience feel a lot of sympathy for Shylock because the audience can now see why Shylock might be the way he is.

Shylock might seem like a villain in the play because all of the people who have treated him he has tried to fight back to, such as the bond between him and Shylock. The audience will feel sorry for him because that people do not treat him in the play the way that he should be treated. Shylock also says:' If you wrong us, shall we not revenge?' This shows that if the Christian people can seek revenge why can't he? The audience will hear this and not hate Shylock so much because he is only trying to balance out the pain he has been through on the people who have caused him the pain. Like when Antonio had spat on him in the past:' You call me misbeliever, cut-throat dog, And you spit upon my Jewish gaberdine, And all for use of that which is mine own.'s o the pain that Shylock has been caused by Antonio is the reason for Shylock and Antonio's bond. Act 4, scene 1 is the courtroom scene and is a very important scene for Shylock's character.

He can gain sympathy in this scene or lose sympathy, so it is very important he doesn't make the audience dislike him in this scene. Throughout this scene Shylock is determined for revenge against Antonio. This will make the audience not give him as much sympathy as they would have if he wasn't so keen to revenge. Near the end of act 4, scene 1 Portia tells Shylock that he cannot get his bond because if he spills the blood of Antonio, it will be against the law. She also says that if he were to cut off more than one pound of Antonio's flesh then he would also be breaking the law.

This does not effect the audience's sympathy for Shylock, but does affect the character Shylock himself, as he now cannot fulfil his bond. Then Portia says:' If it be proved against an alien That by direct or indirect attempts He seek the life of any citizen, The party 'gains t the which he doth contrive Shall seize one half his goods; the other half Comes to the privy coffer of the state; And the offender's life lies in the mercy Of the duke only, 'gains t all other voice. ' After the audience has heard this they will feel a lot more sympathy for Shylock, as he will lose all his possessions and his life. Although some may think that he should be punished like this for what he was going to do to Antonio. Then Antonio says that he will give Shylock back half his possessions if he becomes a Christian and gives all his possessions away to Lorenzo and Jessica when he dies.

Shylock agrees to this but knows he will regret it since if a Jew were to turn Christian then they would be damned to hell. Shylock will be very emotional at this stage and so the audience will start to feel quite a lot of sympathy for Shylock. The audience knows how much Shylock's religion means to him, and they also know how much he hates Christians. If he gives his money to Lorenzo he will be giving his money to a Christian.

Overall, we (the audience) cannot feel much sympathy for Shylock as once we start to feel sorry for him in the play he does something that will make us feel less sympathy for him. The only exception to this is the court scene in which he leaves us feeling sorry for him, and this was after out feelings had changed many times throughout the scene. A contemporary audience's response to Shylock would differ from that of an audience in Shakespeare's time because of what has happened in the world since Shakespeare's time. A contemporary audience would be more likely to give Shylock sympathy than an audience would in Shakespeare's time. This is because in Shakespeare's time Jews were hated.

Many would spit on Jews such as Antonio did so in the play, and many Jews would suffer racial abuse. This would mean that there was a less likely chance of the audience feeling sorry for Shylock. A contemporary audience will not have such a racist view on Jews (Shylock) which is the reason for why they will give more sympathy than an audience will in Shakespeare's time. A contemporary audience would treat Shylock as an equal and would give him the same amount of sympathy as a Christian.

If Shylock was played as a Christian in Shakespeare's time the audience will feel a lot more sympathy towards him about his daughter etc. Overall, the contemporary audience's view would be less racist and more sympathetic towards Shylock than an audience in Shakespeare's time. I feel this is the case because that now there is more rights for Jews and other religions and so many people see them as an equal. Whereas people in Shakespeare's time would feel that the Jews had no right to be living in their country since they have not rights of there own, and were seen as worthless.

They also might have thought that the Jews were ruining their country and they might have wanted their country to not have any 'outsiders' or 'aliens' living in it (they might have wanted their country to be only one religion). They also might have found it abnormal to have people from other religions in a Christian country. A contemporary audience would be less likely to think that a Jew in their country was abnormal. This would mean they would treat them the same as everyone else and so give him as much sympathy as Shylock should be given, and wouldn't be based on anything racial..