Benjys In The Quentin Section example essay topic

A Study of Structure in The Sound and the Fury In his novel, The Sound and the Fury, William Faulkner employs a unique structural assembly to relay a compelling and complex plot to his readers. As he looked upon this work as a failure in its own right, Faulkner revealed, ... I wrote that same story four times. None of them were right... so I printed it in four sections (Millgate 89).

His intention upon writing this novel was not for the sole purpose of creating such a peculiar organization, but simply to relate a short story of, as he put it, ... a little girl with muddy drawers (Hoffman 73). As his work progressed, this divided narrative grew into an almost enigmatic structural masterpiece. M. Cointreau speaks of the divisions as... four movements of a symphony (Millgate 91). These movements, may not become apparent to the reader during his first attempt, but as he begins to listen more carefully to the pitch of Faulkners song, he becomes increasingly conscious of The Sound and the Fury harmonious aura. Critics of The Sound and the Fury are quick to note the scrambled botch of ideas and statements that the reader is faced with in the first section of the novel. The second narration is slightly more coherent but again contains vague concepts. However, once the reader has become familiar with Faulkners technique, a more in depth look can be taken into the similarities and differences between the two characters, Benjy. and Quentin.

The parallelism of the complex structure and other literary attributes within the first two sections of The Sound and the Fury are further developed by looking at the relationships between the contrasting points of view and varying levels of consciousness of Benjy and Quentin. The opening section of the novel is narrated fro the perspective of the character Benjy, a thirty three year old man whose mind is developed no further than one of a child. The individual sentence structure is very simple. This does not mean that the section is simple, but there are no difficult words because the vocabulary of an idiot would naturally be elementary. The first words of Faulkners creation are said by Edel to... take us into a bewildering world, as if we were traversing without pause the ages of man-and in the wrong order (100). This bewildering world can be understood with significantly more clarity when Faulkners stream-of -consciousness technique is identified and studied.

In this method one idea or instance flows into another by the relation of a person, place, or event. For example, in pages 1-3 of the novel, Benjy is walking near a golf course. The images of the area and the voices of the golfers calling for their caddies, remind him of a time almost twenty years prior, when he was taking a walk in the same surroundings with his sister Caddy. The lack of a transition or any other type of explication between these two instances cause the unprepared reader to become confused and frustrated. Faulkner does, however, leave one clue that some form of variance is occurring, as the type style changes to italics.

Therefore, the reader must be constantly aware of the type set and let it be an aid in understanding the novel. With the discernment of the obscure stream technique and the recognition of Faulkners subtle hints, one begins to employ, as Edel calls it, ... a new way of reading fiction (100). Also, stream-of-conciseness can be identified as a technique whereby the author writes as though he is in the minds of the characters. Likewise, Benjys thought can be interrupted halfway through a thought; sometimes he can return to it and sometimes it is lost forever.

The complexity of the structure of this initial section of the novel is comparative to the one which ensues it. Thus, in the Benjy section everything is presented through an apparently unorganized succession of images. Quentin, the character who narrates the second section, as Benjy was the narrator of the first, also produces a stream of consciousness in telling his tale. However, in contrast to Benjy, Quentins stream reveals voluntary and involuntary thoughts and moves between these thoughts much more quickly. As this section progresses he becomes more and more immersed in his voluntary thoughts, as Benjy was only conscious of what came to him naturally. Faulkner builds upon the basic method and combines it with other techniques.

He reveals his characters mind... interacting with the outside world by using external incidents to either aspire or cut off an extended memory (Geismar 200). Faulkner also adopts techniques such as an episode of hallucination, in which no real action occurs at all, for the presentation of a character, ... whose tormented thoughts are in reality driving him to suicide (Geismar 200). In the conclusion of his section Quentin does commit suicide. Therein lies a tone of finality which sheds negative light onto the stream-of-consciousness technique and its self-destructive nature. Whereas Faulkners style is relatively in complex in presenting Benjys simple mind, when he turns to the intricate mind of Quentin his style changes drastically. In Quentins section the reader finds long, complex, and difficult ideas.

Quentin is trying to solve complicated moral issues, therefore his section is more complicated. Also, like Benjys, in the Quentin section everything is presented through random ideas connected by association. In both sections of The Sound and the Fury, Faulkner combines the use of first- person narration with a decisively additional improvement provided by stream-of- consciousness techniques. The first person technique forces each character to reveal himself to the reader, thereby eliminating the possibility of inarticulateness. As an example of this the novel states, Your name is Benjy.

Caddy said. Do you hear... Caddy lifted me under the arms. (75). This episode is relaying Caddy attempts at communication with Benjy, who can only moan in reply. We are maneuvered by the novelist into taking over all of Benjys senses... his eyes become our eyes, his sense of smell is ours, his unique experience of the world around him is ours... though we retain, at the same time, our own awareness (Millgate 90).

What Faulkner has achieved in the Benjy section is a use of language to evoke more perceptions and feelings than the reader has ever experienced in any other unpoetic prose. In Quentins section of The Sound and the Fury the technique dominates, even though Faulkner employs first person narration. Quentins past-tense reporting of the external facts, functions like omniscient third-person narration, whom he himself replaces. He took one look at her and knew that she was the one who loved him the most in the world.

(Faulkner 124). Since a first-person narrator is not aware of others thoughts and feelings unless they are directly revealed to that character, it can be surmised that Quentin was at some times more representative of a omniscient narrator. To report his characters thoughts, Faulkner shifts to a direct reporting technique based on the present tense. For example Quentin says, I dont remember forgetting them. I dont remember how many chins Mrs. Bland has either (Faulkner 175). Since he has taken the place of omniscient narrator, all of the observations are thus limited to his perceptions.

As narrator, Quentin attempts to describe objectively the environment and the events around him. He does this even though his objectivity is nullified from the start by his minds distortions. The apparent objectivity with which he begins each of the opening paragraphs disintegrates almost immediately into a memory of a conversation with his father. The first five paragraphs work this way, but the fifth becomes more complicated as, Quentin inadvertently begins to reveal the stream of his mind. Quentins patterns of association become involuntary, as several thoughts rush into his mind at once, we the readers begin to relate our own consciousness to his, and come upon the realization that we have more thoughts than we care to recognize (Geismar 199). As Quentin, in effect, tries to impose a biased interpretation upon the reader, Benjy does not interpret any situations or events.

Benjys observations do not pass through an intelligence which is capable of ordering. Benjys simplistic and easily confused nature is evident in the statement, They came on. I opened the gate and they stopped, turning. I was trying to say, and I caught her... she screamed... and the bright shapes began to stop... (64). Since this occurs before the reader can understand the events, the section takes on a curious nature that leaves the reader sometimes having to make what he can out of the fragments he was given.

He reports the events of which he is a spectator, and even those in which he himself is a participator, with a camera-like fidelity (Millgate 91). His view of Caddy is highly personal, but the reader infers this view from the scenes that his camera-mind records. He does not judge people himself, although he becomes the instrument by which the other characters are judged. Benjy is the moral reflector of the novel because he can sense things that no one else can. He knows when Quentin committed suicide, when Caddy has been promiscuous, and he knows when his order, or pattern of existence is violated. Benjys ability to sense things gives him a slightly wider view of the world that is inaccessible to him through speech.

The time element in Faulkners work is as essential for the reader to understand as his stream-of-consciousness technique. In Benjys section clock time is almost completely disregarded, because Benjy himself is completely oblivious of time. He makes no distinction between an event that happened only hours ago and one that occurred years ago. Benjys memory of the branch scene when he was ten years old is as vivid in his mind as something that just happened that morning twenty-two years later. Sartre explains that In Faulkners work there is never any progression, never anything which comes from the future (Sartre 88). This is explained by that, if Benjy goes on a walk with Caddy through his field in 1929, it is because he has done so since 1902.

He is as enthusiastic about this walk in 1929 as he was years earlier. The many years that Caddy was not there to walk with him are non-existent to him because he remembers only those events which made him happy. Faulkner displaces conventional time chronicles in order to emphasize Benjys rejection of the difference between various times and, more importantly, to show how actions of the past are important to Benjy because they gave him pleasure. As Benjy is completely oblivious of time, Quentin expends all his energy trying to understand time. Quentins section can be simply regarded a time bomb ticking to its inevitable blast.

This fleeting and unimaginable immobility, can however, be arrested and pondered. Quentin can say I broke my watch, but when he says it his gesture is past. The past takes on a sort of super-reality, with perimeters that are definite and unchangeable. These perimeters are apt to disguise the present, and reappears only when they themselves is past.

Sartre concludes with the following excerpt: The coming suicide which casts a shadow over Quentins last day is not a human possibility; not for a second does Quentin envisage not killing himself. This suicide is an immobile wall, a thing which he approached backward, and which he neither wants to nor can conceive. (91) Quentin is so concerned with this configuration of past events fixed in his mind that the present to him has become submerged in the past. Also, that which is lived in the present is also lived in the past because what was previously the present now is the past. As these complex ideas are slightly confusing, the idea to keep in mind here is that Quentin tries to stop time from passing, and the only way that he can accomplish this is by committing suicide, which he carries out at the end of the section. The Sound and the Fury, a tale narrated by four diverse characters, presents a challenging task to a brave reader with the use of a complex structure and many different literary motifs.

With its extraordinary message of mind over matter it persuades one no to give into the little things in life, like Quentin, but to face all obstacles, like Benjy, and to look forward to each day as if it were ones birthday.