Celie And Jean Muir example essay topic

In an essay of not more than 1500 words, explore the theme of the creation of women's identities in The Color Purple and one other prose text from Literature and Gender, with a detailed examination of how the form of each fiction contributes to the impact of the narratives. Alice Walker's novel The Color Purple has a rich array of female characters to examine when answering the above question. I feel that Louisa May Alcott's short story, "Behind A Mask" offers an equally rich array of female characters to consider. Through the course of this essay I will show how Walker and Alcott used different narrative techniques and made different use of language and dialogue to create their characters; and how they each respectively created very powerful pieces of work, identifying with their characters and the problems and obstacles faced by them in their everyday lives. The Color Purple is written in the epistolary style where the main character writes letters to God. These letters are like a diary where Celie tells her story.

This diary technique contains Celie's innermost thoughts and allows the reader to know the true Celie because she is able to completely open up in her writing. Walker writers the whole story thought Celie's (female) perspective, which is particularly useful when we are given Celie's impression main female characters in the novel, Sophia and Shug. We get a different view of Nettie because she writes her own letters to Celie. Certain key events in Celie's life made her the character she is, for example: her continual rape by her stepfather; the subsequent pregnancies and the loss of her children; the death of her mother; and the loss of her sister, Nettie.

However, through the course of the novel, Celie finds that she has managed to form close relations with the female characters of the novel, she finds love and friendship and is finally reunited with her sister and children who were taken from her. The Color Purple opens, with Celie writing to God, describing herself as "a good girl" (the fact that she addresses her letters to God emphasizes this) and how her stepfather's advances to her mother were rejected, resulting in Celie's rape. Before chapter one even begins we here a pre-echo of Celie's stepfather, "You better not never tell nobody but God. It'd kill your mammy". So Celie learns to keep quiet to survive and this is a habit that is hard for her to break. Celie is a passive character.

She is hardworking and domesticated and this is what allows her to be married off so young. Celie's father and husband describe her as ugly and stupid but she is able to work and look after children. Celie is made to feel worthless by the men in her life. She misses out on the education that Nettie receives and this is apparent when comparing their styles of writing.

Celie writes in the vernacular. This adds some authenticity to her character, makes it easier to sympathise with her. Nettie is one of the few stimuli that turn Celie passive to active. When she finds out that Albert has been intercepting Nettie's letters, she wants to kill him.

Shug has to hold her back. Celie is in awe of Shug and Sophia. Both women show spirit and strength of character. Shug is infamous in the area, particularly due to her long-standing relationship with the married Albert, Until the arrival of Shug, Celie lived in fear of Albert (understandably considering the basis of their marriage) and she is amazed to see the effect Shug has on Albert, reducing him almost into a little boy. When Celie and Shug become friends, Celie's life improves dramatically. Not only does she now have a close female friend but Shug is able to use her influence and discourage Albert from beating Celie.

Towards the end of the novel, the relationship that Albert and Celie both have with Shug draws them together and although Albert asks Celie to marry him again, she declines. Sexually she has no interest in men but is happy to remain friends. At the end of The Color Purple Celie and Albert manage to form a friendship that they didn't have when they were married. Celie stood up to Albert and had the courage to leave him. After this he made effort to be clean and to try to change himself. This is a major turning point for Celie.

Instead of feeling that she cannot control things and that she can only allow things to happen to her, she realise's that her actions can have consequences and the reactions can be good. In Shug, Celie finds someone to love. This area of her life has been empty. Everyone that Celie had the potential to love was taken from her. Although her love for Shug is sexual, there is also a deep bond of friendship between the two women. Compare Celie with the main character of Louisa May Alcott's Behind a Mask.

Jean Muir's character could not be much further removed from Celie's in The Color Purple. As much as Celie is a passive character, Jean Muir is active, controlling and manipulative. Until the end of the story she plans and controls the events in the Coventry household. There are, however, some similarities between Jean Muir and Celie. Both disguise themselves, Celie behind her mask of tolerance and passivity and Jean Muir hides behind a mask of domesticity and compliance. But Alcott does not only use "mask" metaphorically, at the end of the first chapter Jean Muir really does remove her "mask" when she retires for the evening she removes false hair and teeth and makeup revealing a haggard woman beneath.

Jean Muir is acting out a role. She uses her acting ability to meet her own ends. She had been an actress but must keep this secret because it is an occupation considered unfit for a young lady. But she is wily enough to know in order to succeed in her plan she must at least give the impression she meets all society's requirements and expectations of a young lady, like cousin Lucia, who Jean Muir describes as cold. She even refers to her "acting" as a "scene" commenting to Gerald, who's suspicions seem to be aroused by her fainting spell, "Thanks.

The last scene shall be still better". Alcott's short story is a mystery, a thriller. From the outset we can sense that Jean Muir is not who she says she is, we know something is amiss but are kept in suspense. Alcott could not have used the same narration technique as Alice Walker because that would have allowed too much insight into the character and removed the suspense. Alice Walker wanted us to know what life was like for Celie, and Alcott wanted us to remain on the edge of our seats as we read. But Alcott does make use of the same epistolary method as Alice Walker, when Jean Muir reveals her true intentions in her letters to her friend, Hortense.

Just as Celie exposes herself in her letters to God, so Jean Muir does the same when writing to her friend. She lets her guard down, even gloats at how her plans are beginning to work. These letters give us an insight into Jean Muir's issues. In her first letter she comments on the way family greeted her, using the words: indolence, rudeness, patronizingly, pride, coldness and insolence to describe the Coventry family. She is disgusted by their superior attitude towards her. Jean Muir has issues with the class system and being discriminated against on the grounds of her class.

She pretends that she is the daughter of a Lady and the family's attitudes towards her change. These issues are similar to Sophia's issues in The Color Purple who cannot conceal her feelings when confronted by the white Mayor and his wife who suggest that she would make a good maid. Sophia does not believe they are any better than she is and is disgusted at their racial prejudice. Unlike Jean Muir who can mask her true feelings, Sophia lets her feelings rule her and they are the ruination of her. Both Celie and Jean Muir use their exteriors to camouflage their true feelings but whilst Celie feels sadness and a desire for love, Jean Muir feels bitter and a need for revenge. The most marked difference between Celie and Jean Muir is how they use their sexuality (Shug is much more aware of how to use her sexuality effectively than Celie is).

Jean Muir uses her sexuality to manipulate the three main male characters of the story, particularly Sir John Coventry who is totally taken in by her act. She wants a title and uses her femininity, flattering the elderly gentleman. Sir John is amazed at such a lovely young woman being interested in him, for although Jean Muir is not described as pretty, her mysterious air provokes interest. Behind a Mask is a short story compared to The Color Purple and this results in the pace being faster. The two stories have nothing in common but their main female characters do share some characteristics, particularly in the way they have learned to hide behind the facade of how acceptable women in society should beY. Approaching Literature: Literature and Gender (1996) Goodman L (ed), The Open University.

The Color Purple B (1992) Walker Alice, The Women's Press.