Grand Inquisitor example essay topic

The Grand Inquisitor The Grand Inquisitor reflects Fyodor Dostoevsky interest in religious and political issues. Dostoevsky uses the voices of his characters to express his views on the legitimacy of the Roman Catholic Church and role of religion in society. The story centers around the conflict between the Grand Inquisitor and Jesus. Jesus returns to Earth during the Spanish Inquisition, when in which Jews and Muslims were forced to convert to Christianity and were murdered if not devoted in their belief.

The Grand Inquisitor examines the relationship between man and Christ through a unique narrative style that adds various depths of meaning to the story. To begin with, the most striking feature of this work is that it is a story within a story. The Grand Inquisitor is part of the novel entitled The Brother's Karamazov, in which Dostoevsky has already introduced the two brothers, Alyosha and Ivan. In The Grand Inquisitor, however, Ivan is the author of the legend of the Grand Inquisitor, a story poem that he is telling to Alyosha. Through this type of writing, Dostoevsky has created multiple levels of narration, which is truly remarkable.

In the first few lines of the story, for example, we are uncertain as to who is the narrator, "God our Lord, reveal thyself to us', for so many centuries they had calling out to him, that in his immeasurable compassion desired to descend to these who were pleading... he had descended even before then, he had visited some righteous men, martyrs, and holy hermits while they were still on earth, as is written in their lives". The narrator explains his role and reveals himself in the next few lines, "my action is set in Spain, in Servile, in the most horrible time of the Inquisition, when fires blazed everyday to the glory of God... ". Once the Inquisitor begins to speak, his words take up the majority of the story, thus leaving little room for any other comments.

In fact, when Alyosha asks Ivan a question, Ivan dismisses the question and suggests Alyosha focuses on what the Inquisitor is saying, not on the insignificant detail. For instance, this conversation between Ivan and Alyosha illustrates that point, "I don't quite understand what this is Ivan... is it boundless fantasy or some mistake on the old man's part, some impossible qui pro quo? ... Ivan laughed... but isn't it all the same to me whether it's qui pro quo or boundless fantasy? The only thing is that the old man needs to speak out, as say aloud all that he has been silent about for ninety years". The Inquisitor, a ninety-year-old cardinal of the Roman Catholic Church, condemns the action of Jesus and imprisons him during the Spanish Inquisition.

This conflict between the Inquisitor and Jesus, who is represented as God and is a result of the Inquisitor believes that Jesus is no longer needed on Earth. The Roman Catholic Church, represented though the Inquisitor symbolizes mans religion. The Inquisitor believes that the Church has a better grasp on what society needs and how to provide it. The Inquisitor argues that God has the ability to give to man what he needs, but he refused in order to strengthen individual fate. The Inquisitor argues that the majority of the people in society are not strong enough to survive on their own, and need direct control. The Inquisitor uses the loaves of bread story to demonstrate this point, "better that you enslave us, but freed us.

They finally understand that freedom and earthly bread in plenty for everyone are inconceivable together, for never, never will they be able to share among themselves... You promised them heavenly bread, but I repeat again can it compare with earthly bread in the eyes of the weak, eternally depraved, and eternally ignoble human race? " Dostoevsky allows Ivan to give life to the ideas of the Inquisitor, who represents the fundamental philosophies of the Roman Catholic Church. Ironically, the entire time that the Inquisitor is speaking, Jesus remains silent and does not defend himself against the accusations.

Dostoevsky is expressing his views on Catholicism through Ivan, as the Inquisitor. As a Russian Orthodox, Dostoevsky believed that the Pope was simply the "middleman" and completely unnecessary for the faith. The Russian Orthodox Church allowed people to be closer to God and stressed a direct relationship between man and God. The significance of the speech, therefore, is not that the Inquisitor is speaking to Jesus, because Jesus does not reply, but in the message of his words because they supposedly reflect the ideas of the Roman Catholic Church.

In The Grand Inquisitor, Dostoevsky suggests, through Ivan, that man wants to and must be controlled. Furthermore, he suggests that religion contributes to maintaining order needed in a society. The Grand Inquisitor has multiple levels of meaning and depth; it is like peeling an onion with each layer adding to the meaning of the story. The most interesting event happens at the end, in which the Inquisitor and the releases the prisoner, .".. when the Inquisitor fell silent, he waited some time for his prisoner to reply. His silence weighed on him... But suddenly he approaches the old man in silence and gently kisses him on his bloodless, ninety -year-old lips.

That is the whole answer. The old man shudders. Something stirs at the corner of his mouth; he walks to the door, opens it, and says to him: Go and do not come again... do not come at all... never, never!" This event, although at the end of the story, is important because it illustrates the unwavering power and unconditional love that Jesus has for man. Dostoyevsky allows reader from various religious backgrounds the see that the most important relationship is that between God and man.