Natures Attitude To Man example essay topic

Robert Frost: Poem Analysis Gregory GeismarDISCUSS FROSTS TREATMENT OF NATURE IN ANY THREE POEMS YOU HAVE STUDIED REFER TO MANS ATTITUDE TO NATURE IS FROSTS ATTITUDE TRADITIONAL OR MODERN EXPLORE THE POETS USE OF LANGUAGE POEMS: TWO LOOK AT TWO TREE AT MY WINDOW IN HARDWOOD GROVES If one looks at mans attitude to nature in the three poems then there are many similarities and differences. In Two Look at Two one gets the feeling that nature is unhappy and angry at man and the destruction that he causes. With barbed-wire binding. The image of barbed wire is quite unnatural, it is a man made barrier, which has been placed in an area where there should be no sign of anything constructed or built by humans. The fact that man has put the obstacle there indicates that he takes nature very much for granted and only thinks what is best for him and not the surrounding area i.e. the animals, birds and plant life etc. Natures attitude to man is summed up in the does reaction to man, she sighed and passed un scared along the wall.

The does actions reinforces the idea that nature is not interested in something that wherever it goes it has to take over and impose itself. Nature does not take kindly to this and thus ignores it. The bucks actions as well show how nature truly views us, why dont you make some you cant. Here the roles are reversed usually it is us, man, who judges nature, pointing, staring and wondering why the animals seem so lifeless. However here the buck does the same thing to us realising that we are nothing special and that it would prefer to carry living its life rather than be a human.

The tone at this point in the poem is angry, almost scornful and aggressive summing up just how nature feels about us. The irony in the poem is the fact that ma thinks they have come away from the event having experienced some kind of transcendence, As if the earth their love. They think they have showed care for nature and in exchange nature has returned their love. However this could not be further from the truth, man is completely oblivious to his surroundings and only feels what he wants to, nature is in-fact completely un-interested in them.

Tree at My Window, renews faith that there can be a relationship between man and nature. In this poem a true bond is demonstrated with a tree and what I would imagine to be a young child looking out for each other at all costs. But let there never be curtain drawn, neither want there to be any sort of barrier between them. This illustrates profoundly that man and nature can have a relationship if there is nothing in their way, nothing un-natural.

What struck me most about the poem was that even though the tree and the man have to contend with different surroundings and events (the tree with the elements, the child with mood and temperament) they could still look out for each other and develop an affiliation. If one looks at, In Hardwood Groves, then you can see that Frost is talking about the essence of nature and the cycle of life, The same leaves over and over again! Frost is presenting simple but essential truths on his observations of nature. In this poem Frost does not really have a judgement on nature but he perceives what life is all about and how we are all just on a clock going towards death. If you look at Two Look at Two, then Frosts attitude seems to be modern. This is down to the fact that he is representing a real life situation, where people from the city or urban areas travel to the countryside expecting some kind of transcendent experience with nature.

They go away thinking they have this but really nature hasnt returned any of their interest. The essence that makes this poem modern is the fact that the humans discard nature and take it for granted, not realising that it thinks and feels and is not just there to be pointed and stared at. The couples attitude is modern, as they do not have a clue how nature wants to be treated, how they must respect and cherish it, typical of city / urban people now days. In Tree at My Window, I found it more of a traditional poem. The poem brings to mind a situation, which would have happened years ago rather than in modern days. It talks about the bond that can develop between human and nature, how they can respect each other and get along with each other.

It is not a situation that I think you would see in the 21st century, sadly. It also talks about how there should be no barrier between man and nature, however that is the opposite of now a days with their being so many physical obstacles separating the two. I also found In Hardwood Groves, quite a traditional poem. In this Frost is taking the attitude that leaves live, solely there to give shade, they then die, and the whole cycle starts again, They fall from giving shade above, this is a very conventional opinion to have. He ignores the fact that leaves can be there for beauty but also and more importantly to help us breath and keep the planet going. Robert Frosts viewpoint here is traditional further in the fact that he seems to be taking for granted the need we have for leaves, and he is very firm on his opinion, I know that this is the way in ours.

The use of language in In Hardwood Groves, conveys a feeling of frustration, The same leaves over and over again! This first line indicates to me that the poet is aggravated and concerned by the same continual cycle that the leaves take. Lines 7 and 8 suggest a childlike intuition of things as they really are. Words such as dark and decayed symbolism the ideas of death and resurrection, themes that appear in Frosts other poems. The continual use of must in lines 7-9 reinforce the idea that the cycle the leaves have to take is unavoidable and in order for a new generation to be born they have to go through those routes. The language in Tree at My Window is very variate d.

The first two stanzas are relaxed and tranquil, vague dream-head lifted out of the ground, this line particularly typifies the calmness of the first two stanzas. However the last two stanzas then suddenly become more serious. Frost starts to use more intensely emotive language, tossed and swept giving a sense of desperation and urgency to the tone of the poem. Frosts use of language manages to identify with the tree and the human whilst still being able to insist on the differences between them.