Philip And Bains example essay topic

Compare The Portrayal Of Childhood In Charles Dickens Great Expectations And Graham Greenes The Charles Dickens Great expectations and Graham Greenes The Fallen Idol both portray childhood in very interesting and motivating ways. Great Expectations is a pre 20th century novel, showing how pips upbringing affects his childhood. The Fallen Idol shows many similarities as well as differences to Great Expectations to childhood based in the 20th century. Both texts are set out in very different ways.

Great Expectations is a bildungsroman, which tracks the life of the main character, in this case, Pip. A bildungsroman follows all issues and themes throughout the lie and growth of the main character. It also shows other characters lives, but revolves around the main character. However, The Fallen Idol is a short story, which does not focus on anyones life, but only shows a short story, which revolves around a particular theme or issue. A short story follows at most a week, but may skip some time periods, on order to get to a particular issue or moral that the writer wants to achieve. Pip From Great Expectations and Philip from The Fallen Idol have many similarities as well as differences throughout both stories.

Pip, is an orphan, who lives with his sister, miss Joe Gargery, and her husband, Joe Gargery. Throughout all of his childhood, he lives his sister and Joe Gargery. Pips parents dies when he was very young. He fells he has memories of his parents and his family, as he explains they were unreasonably derived from their tombstones (Chapter 1, Page 5). Pip describes their death as unreasonable (Chapter 1, Page 5), stressing that he never had the chance to see them, not even in a photograph or painting, because he was too young to remember. Pip lives in a poor household, due to Joe bein a low paid Blacksmith.

He does not have many privileges, as well as physical objects, because he lives in such a poor household. This greatly affects his lifestyle and childhood. Philip on the other hand is very wealthy. In similarity to Pip, Philips parents are not in the story.

This is not for the same reasons as Pip, which is their death, but is because his parents are on vacation. Staff of his parents, Bains and Mrs Bains, are caring for Philip. Throughout the short story, Bains and Mrs Bains look after and care for Philip. Philip is therefore made to live with people of lower class than him. There are two other characters in the stories, which bare great similarities. Joe, from Great expectations and Bains from The Fallen Idol has much in common that effects the childhood of the boys.

Joe Gargery, who cares for Pip, seems like a father and brother for pip, and takes the role of father in Pips life, due to the death of Pips birth father. Pip and Joe have a close relationship, to which Pip also loves and sees Joe as more of a brother. I always treated him as a large species of child and no more than my equal This shows that Pip sees him as more of a large child than an adult. The equal in the quote shows that he sees Joe as an equal to him, meaning that he treats Joe as a brother. This also shows Joe is much respected by Pip. Philip and Bains also have a close relationship.

Philip feels freer when he is with Bains. Philip loves Bains. They both have a close relationship because they trust and love each other. Bains cares for, and looks after Philip. Because Philip deeply respects Bains, he feels angry and disappointed at himself for letting out the secret of Bains affair. There is some love that Bains has for Philip, but there is obviously more love for Bains that Philip has, than love that Bains has for Philip.

Comparing both stories, I think that Joe has more love for Pip, than Bains has for Philip; mainly due to the family relationship i.e. Bains is merely a worker, whilst Joe is family related. Despite the loving relationship that the men have for the boys, there is a great difference that the women have for the boys. In both stories, the women dominate Philip and Pip. Pips sister, Mrs Joe Gargery, is very aggressive to Pip. She is not gentle with dealing with him. She does not like him much because she does not see why she had to take care of him and bring him up by hand, because she sees him as ungrateful.

Unlike Joe, she is not a mother figure, nor does not act like one. She repeatedly makes him feel guilty. Who bought you up by hand Why I do it I should like to know Because she makes him feel guilty for raising him, she makes it seem as an effort, and that she is doing a great favour for him. I see that she loves him, but she does not show it much. It shows that she loves him, because she tries very hard so that he can have the best i.e. she arranges him to meet with Ms Hav isham, a potential benefactor, so that he will be able to have money. Throughout his childhood, many females treat him bad.

Estella also treats him bad. She makes fun out of him, and treats him as if he is worthless because he is of a lower class that she is. The female character, Mrs Bains, also intimidates Philip. Like Mrs Gargery, Mrs Bains treats Philip aggressively and treats him rough.

She was so like the witches in his dreams The relationship between Philip and Mrs Bains, is neither loving nor caring Philip obviously hates her shown by him bravely saying to her I hate you. There is one reason thinkable why Mrs Bains dislikes Philip. This reason is that Philip does not listen to Mrs Bains, and is disrespectful. If she tells him to do something, he will ignore her, and do what Bains tells him to do. Mrs Bains has power, which she uses to control Philip as well as Bains. There is a very definitive similarity in both stories, which involves Magwitch, the escape convict, and Bains.

Bains tells Philip to keep a secret about his affair, as does Magwitch tells Pip to help keep a secret that he is an escape convict. Philip knows he is an escape convict, because Magwitch has shackles around his feet. Magwitch also threatens Philip and makes Philip bring him food and a file, to break open the shackles. This secrecy and fear of keeping the secret greatly affects the childhood of both Philip and Pip. The childhood throughout both stories are perceived in positive, as well as in negative ways. Philip questions life, and is confused with the influences.

Philip has a traumatic time in the story, due to his Idol - Bains falling because Pip loses respect, because Mrs Bains is murdered by Bains. Pip also has a depressing and traumatic childhood, due to the women treating him badly. Both children do have a little happiness, due to the loving men, Joe being the father figure, and Bains being a carer..