Progress In Roark's Eye In His Soul example essay topic
Ellsworth Toohey is the embodiment of evil. His ambition is not only to physically own people but also to capture possession of their souls by breaking them down and in this way he gains power over them. He confesses to Peter that, 'If you learn how to rule one single man's soul, you can get the rest of man kind. It's the soul Peter, not whips or swords or fire or guns... it must be broken' (635). Toohey understands that the world is full of Peter Keatings', the ones that need reassurance and recognition from others. He made it very clear that he wanted power.
"I want my world of the future. Let all sacrifice and none profit. Let all suffer and none enjoy. Let progress stop' (639). He also saw this progress in Roark's eye, in his soul and in his work and he despised him for it.
He knew very well that great men can't be ruled and 'Anything that can't be ruled must go' (638). That was the reason he had to destroy Roark. He believed that by praising the Keatings of the world and laughing at the Roark, he would manipulate the public to condemn and destroy the only man that could save them from themselves. Ellsworth believed that he had succeeded and that he had the power because he ruled the public, but he did not. He found this out when the jury found Roark not guilty. For this verdict it meant that the world he had believed to have owned was ready to embrace Roark's philosophies and was ready for the things that Toohey hated the most: individualism and progress.
Toohey had failed, Roark had won and this destroyed Toohey. Gail Wynand, a rugged newspaper industrialist, had succeeded in becoming one of the wealthiest men of his time. He owned everything within his reach, but lacked the possession of his own soul. He sold this to the public and in return inherited power. He had created a paper containing things that the public wanted to hear. Wynand's destruction was due to his carelessness in maintaining his integrity.
He puts everything that he has at risk to protect Roark and himself and he writes only things that defend Roark in The Banner. But after an unexpected cold reception of the new magazine, Wynand realizes that he has no power. But the last event was when Roark was found 'not guilty'. He realized that he had given up his integrity in order to gain what he thought was power, but in the end he did not have to. His whole life was pointless and he had become the man he did not want to become and could never be the man he dreamt of being. Peter Keating flows through a transition of vanity, fame, lies, flattery and eventually guilt.
He lacks self-respect and therefore people easily govern him. He envies Roark's talent and passion and for that he would ask him to design many of the buildings that he could not do. Roark says that 'he's not really struggling even for material wealth, but for the second-hand er's delusion- prestige, a stamp of approval, not his own. He can find no struggle, no joy when he has succeeded. He can't say about a single thing' This is what I wanted, because I wanted it, not because it made my neighbors gape at me' (607).
It was this second-hand er's delusion that lead to his eventual ruin. After the society that made him and supported him, abandons him, he runs to Roark and begs him to get him back in the public eye by designing the Cortlandt homes for him, but when Toohey forces him to revel the truth to the public during the trail, every ounce of dignity and self-respect that he still had was taken away from him. He was no longer important, he no longer would receive praise for Roark's work and it destroyed him. Dominique Franc on was a strong, powerful, highly intelligent, cold and radiantly beautiful woman that believed that good could never conquer evil and she simply hated everyone.
She had never believed that she could have met her match, until she met Roark because he surpassed her in every aspect. From the beginning their whole relationship was a power struggle. Until they slept together, Dominique began to realize that she could never dominate him. He had to prove his dominance to her, something that she had yet to experience.
I personally do not think Roark raped her because both received pleasure out of this act. She fought him, but she did not scream for help. 'She knew that it was an act that could be preformed in tenderness, as a seal of love, or in contempt, as a symbol of humiliation and conquest... he did it as an act of scorn. Not as love, but as defilement. And this made her lie still and submit' (217). 'She would not take a bath.
She knew that she wanted to keep the feeling of his body, the traces of his body on hers' (217). This was the first step towards Dominique's metamorphosis. Since Dominique had been conquered for the first time, she would try to ruin him because he was pure and good. She expects he will fail and tries her best to prevent him from reaching any success so he will not suffer the dejection of society's ridicule.
It is during her marriage to Wynand that she realized that she was wrong and that she could not let things get to her. After seven long years, she finally understood how things could only hurt down to a certain point and she no longer feared the world. 'She had not been able to accept the Stoddard Trail, she had run from the dread of seeing him (Roark) hurt by the world, but she had agreed to help him in this. Had agreed in complete serenity.
She was free and she and he knew it' (613). The Courtlandt Trail had set her free, she had regained her trust in mankind. She no longer had to 'protect' Roark from defeat and she started to believe that good could prevail. She was in love and she was not too proud to admit it.
He had done the unthinkable, he had dominated Dominique. ' Howard... willingly, completely, and always... without reservations, without fear or anything they can do to you or to me... in anyway you wish... as your wife or as your mistress, secretly or openly... here, or in a furnished room. I'll take in some town near a jail where I'll see you through a wire net... it won't matter... you " ve won long ago... I'll remain what I am, and I'll remain with you-now and ever-in any way you want' (668).
Although at first Roark did not seem to be essential, he prevails as not only the winner but as the one soul man who was responsible for effecting everyone's life in major ways. He was a self-centered, self-generated and self-sufficient, he is the perfect man in every sense. He did what he wanted to do and was very stubborn when someone tried to order him around. He was satisfied and happy with everything that he did and had no regrets.
Ultimately he is the only one that comes out completely victorious.