Troy Of The Trojan War example essay topic

"Archaeology has proved the historicity of the Trojan War". Discuss.".. he [Heinrich Schliemann] found layers of ruins... and two bore unmistakable signs of violent destruction. One of these layers, the seventh according to more recent excavators, was no doubt the city of Priam and Hector. The historicity of the Homeric tale had been demonstrated archaeologically". - M.I. Finley, the World of Odysseus Introduction The Trojan War and its characters are detailed in the writings of Homer, Vergil, Dante and many others.

It is a fantastical tale of a decade-long siege of a powerful city by a massive pan-hellenic force. However, even though it has proved to be such a rich source of inspiration for writers, poets and artists throughout history, it is debated whether it actually took place. Heinrich Schliemann famously said "I have gazed on the face of Agamemnon". on discovering tombs with the bodies of Mycenaean chieftains in Turkey. The German businessman-turned-archaeologist claimed to have discovered the city of Troy at the hill now called Hisarlik - about three miles from the Dardanelles.

However, his claims are still disputed today. Before tackling the question of whether the Trojan War actually occurred, we must ask in what form. What exactly do we mean by "the Trojan War"? There is no definitive version of the events in the war, as our knowledge of it comes from a myriad different sources.

Then we should consider Schliemann's discoveries, and the other archaeological evidence for the Trojan War. Finally, after we have defined "Trojan War" in context of archaeology and historical fact, we must then draw conclusions about the extent to which archaeology proves its historical authenticity. What do we mean by the "Trojan War"? The first source that comes to mind is the writings of Homer - the Iliad and the Odyssey. The two epics are considered canon.

However, Heroditus' Histories briefly detail the major events of the war, and relays them as if they were historical fact. Heroditus' account of the war differs slightly from Homer's version, and he is well aware of this. After relating the tale of Alexander (Paris) carrying off Helen, Heroditus writes: "Such was the tale told me by the priests concerning the arrival of Helen at the court of Proteus. It seems to me that Homer was acquainted with this story, and while disregarding it, because he thought it less adapted for heroic poetry than the version the he followed... ". - Heroditus, Histories book 2 chapter 116 But the Trojan War's historicity was not questioned by the Greeks.

Thucydides, much like Heroditus, believed that it had happened, though he does concede that Homer had changed the story in creating his poetry. Other authors who have drawn on the Trojan War include Plato, Vergil and Dante. Though the Trojan War was an event from early Greek history, the Romans too wrote about it. Vergil's unfinished Aeneid tells the story of Aeneas. Indeed, classical civilisations did not have a monopoly on the Trojan War - Ulysses (Odysseus latinized) appears alongside Diomedes (another leader of the Achaeans who, amongst other deeds, went inside the famous Trojan Horse) in Dante's Inferno. Because so many authors have written about the Trojan War, there are conflicting versions of events.

However, we can compare the different versions and conclude that anything that is repeated in each of the sources actually happened. At the most basic level, we can say that the Trojan War was a pan-hellenic assault on the city of Troy, which after a protracted siege, the attackers were the victors. (If we do not take it for granted that the Trojan War was an attack on the Trojans, then there is very little reason for calling it the "Trojan War". ) The other problems with the surviving accounts of the Trojan War are the involvement of the gods. Supposedly Apollo and Poseidon helped build Troy as punishment. Throughout the Aeneid, the gods aid mortals in their own particular struggles.

Obviously, if the Trojan War did happen, then it did so without the involvement of deities. These incidents of divine intervention were added in order to add further drama and emphasise the scale of the struggle for victory. I personally think that Heroditus' version of the Trojan War is the closest to the truth. When he was writing his Histories he had access to sources we did not, like the priests he mentioned in the above quotation.

His version of events, though it may not be completely accurate, is highly feasible and fits with our existing knowledge of the Mycenaean period. Archaeological evidence If Homer's writings are central to our understanding of the Trojan War, so are Heinrich Schliemann's digs. His name is synonymous with Troy. Fascinated with Homer, he made it his mission to discover Troy, and eventually did. However, his problems with convincing his fellow academics and archaeologists that he had indeed Troy is similar to the problem we have with defining what the Trojan War actually is. Homer's Trojan War could not have possibly happened as it is laid out in the Iliad and the Odyssey.

There are jarring incongruities between what happens in his epics, and what happened in that period of Greek history. "In like manner, if Apollo vouchsafe me glory and I slay your champion, I will strip him of his armour and take it to the city of Ili us, where I will hang it in the temple of Apollo, but I will give up his body, that the Achaeans may bury him at their ships, and the build him a mound by the wide waters of the Hellespont". - Homer, the Iliad book 7: 78-80 We know for a fact that the Greeks had no temples in the Mycenaean period. Homer's poems must therefore not be considered gospel, even if we ignore all references to the gods' intervention. It would be best to look for a city that resembles the Troy portrayed in the Iliad, a Troy that inspired Homer's verse. But if we are not using the epic poetry as a base, then any city supposedly identified as Troy cannot be proved to be Troy.

Schliemann was convinced that he had found Troy:" With great joy I announce to Your Majesty that I have discovered the tombs which the tradition proclaimed by Pausanias indicates to be the graves of Agamemnon, Cassandra, Eurymedon and their companions, all slain at a banquet by Clytemnestra and her lover Aegisthus". - telegram from Schliemann to King George of Greece Nine different cities were found at Hisarlik - each built on the previous one's ruins. The seventh city is generally agreed to be the Troy of the Trojan War. Its towers and sixteen-feet thick walls are still visible today as ruins. Archaeological dating techniques have given us the dates of each layer. The main reason for the controversy surrounding Troy's identification is the paucity of archaeological evidence. Wolf-Dietrich Niemeier, a modern-day archaeologist currently, formerly a professor of archaeology at the University of Heidelberg was interviewed on the importance of Troy: .".. it's always a question of preservation.

The lower city was largely destroyed by later building activities, so all that remains are remnants of houses and some pottery. Perhaps the city was plundered when it was destroyed around 1200 B.C. If it's true that Mycenaean conquered Troy, they-or whoever-would certainly have plundered the city... In addition, the top of the Troy VI citadel was cut away in the fourth century B.C. for the construction of a sanctuary of Athena. In this part of the citadel, we would have expected to find the palace of Troy's royalty or rulers, with rich finds and writings, possibly even an archive of clay tablets.

But it's all gone-all cleared away during the Hellenistic construction of the fourth century B.C". - extract from an interview with Hershel Shanks Taking Heroditus' Trojan War as a guide for what to look for archaeologically we encounter less difficulties. I made enquiries of the priests, whether the story which the Greeks tell about Ilium [Troy] is a fable or no. In reply they related the following particulars... The Greeks... laid siege to the town, and never rested till they finally took it. - Heroditus, Histories book 2 chapter 118 Heroditus also covers his back by going on to question the feasibility of the scenario - war being declared for sake of Helen of Sparta.

But the very lack of details given gives us a lot more scope. All we have to find is a city that existed in the right period in history, of the right size and power. Schliemann's Troy certainly corresponds to Heroditus' Troy. What we are looking for archaeologically depends upon what our definition of the Trojan War is. If we merely consider it to be a battle that was fought at Troy, then there is plenty of archaeological evidence that a Trojan War happened.

Conclusion Archaeology has proved the existence of Troy, but not the historicity of the Trojan War. Even if we do settle on a definition of what exactly the Trojan War was then any conclusion we draw as to whether or not it happened are only apply to that definition of the war - and what we reckon the Trojan War is is a matter of personal belief and not fact. Perhaps a more suitable question would be "Has archaeology proved the historicity of the Iliad?" , or even "Did the version of events Heroditus describes have any foundation in truth?" . If the existence of Troy itself is uncertain, then the historicity of the war can only be more so.

Bibliography

Ancient Sources: - Homer, the Aeneid, translated by Samuel Butler, taken from web - Homer, the Aeneid, translated by T.E. Lawrence (Wordsworth, 1995) - Homer, the Odyssey, translated by T.
E. Lawrence (Wordsworth, 1995) - Heroditus, Histories, translated by George Rawlinson (Wordsworth, 1996) Modern Sources: - Boardman, Griffin and Murray, the Oxford History of the Classical World (Oxford University Press, 1986) - Finley, M.
I., the World of Odysseus, (New York: The Viking Press, 1978) - Finley, M.
I., Ancient History - Evidence and Models, (Penguin, 1985) - Alan B.
Lloyd (editor), Battle in Antiquity (Duckworth, 1996) - Heinrich Schliemann's Telegrams taken from web Wolf-Dietrich Niemeier interview extract from Hershel Shanks, taken from web Additional research taken from Ian Johnston's web page web and also web.